If you own a home in Asheville’s historic district, understanding roofing guidelines is essential. This guide helps you navigate preservation requirements while maintaining your home’s historic character and value.
_______________________________

Navigating Asheville’s Historic District Roofing Guidelines: A Homeowner’s Guide

Understanding Asheville’s Historic District Roofing Requirements

Owning a home in one of Asheville’s cherished historic districts comes with unique responsibilities, especially when it comes to roofing. Historic homes contribute to our city’s character and cultural heritage, which is why specific guidelines exist to preserve their authenticity. But don’t worry – these rules aren’t meant to make your life difficult. They’re in place to protect the value and charm that make your historic home special.

At Lane Roofing and Restoration, we’ve helped countless Asheville homeowners navigate these preservation requirements while ensuring their homes remain protected and beautiful. This guide will walk you through what you need to know about historic district roofing guidelines, from material requirements to the approval process.

Why Historic District Guidelines Matter

Asheville’s historic districts showcase architectural styles that tell the story of our city’s development. When you maintain your roof according to preservation guidelines, you’re not just following rules – you’re helping preserve Asheville’s unique character for future generations.

These guidelines serve several important purposes:

First, they maintain the visual harmony of historic neighborhoods. A historically appropriate roof keeps your home in tune with its neighbors and the district’s overall aesthetic.

Second, they protect your property value. Homes in well-preserved historic districts often appreciate faster than those in areas without such protections.

Finally, they ensure historically accurate materials and techniques are used when possible, preserving authentic craftsmanship.

Key Roofing Guidelines for Asheville’s Historic Districts

Approved Materials

The Historic Resources Commission typically favors materials that match what was originally used on your home. In Asheville, this often means:

Slate – Many older, high-end homes in Montford and Biltmore Village originally featured slate roofs. If your home had slate, you’ll likely need to repair or replace with matching slate.

Wood shingles – Common on Craftsman-style homes and bungalows. Modern fire-treated wood shingles can satisfy both historic requirements and safety codes.

Clay tile – Found on some Spanish Revival or Mediterranean-influenced homes. These distinctive tiles are key to maintaining architectural authenticity.

Metal roofing – Standing seam metal roofs have been used in Asheville for generations and are often approved for many historic homes.

Replacement vs. Repair

The commission typically prefers repair over replacement whenever possible. This preserves original materials and craftsmanship. When damage is extensive, partial replacement matching the original materials is the next preferred option. Complete replacement is considered when repair isn’t feasible.

Color and Texture Requirements

Roof color and texture should be historically appropriate for your home’s age and style. The Historic Resources Commission may require samples or documentation showing your chosen materials match the original roof or are appropriate for your home’s period.

The Approval Process

Before starting any roofing work in a historic district, you’ll need approval from Asheville’s Historic Resources Commission. Here’s what the process typically involves:

First, submit an application detailing your proposed roofing work, including materials, colors, and any changes to roof features like dormers or chimneys.

Next, the commission reviews your application. Minor repairs using matching materials may qualify for expedited approval, while major changes require full commission review.

If approved, you’ll receive a Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) allowing you to proceed. This document is necessary before obtaining regular building permits.

Working with a roofing contractor familiar with historic district requirements can make this process much smoother. At Lane Roofing, we’ve guided many homeowners through this process, helping them prepare proper documentation and choose compliant materials.

Balancing Preservation with Modern Needs

We understand that historic homes must still meet modern needs for energy efficiency, weather resistance, and maintenance. Good news – there are ways to satisfy both preservation requirements and practical concerns.

Modern versions of historic materials often offer improved performance while maintaining authentic appearance. For example, synthetic slate provides the look of natural slate with lighter weight and better durability.

Hidden improvements like upgraded underlayment materials can enhance weather protection without changing your roof’s appearance.

Energy efficiency can be improved through properly ventilated attic spaces and insulation improvements that don’t affect the roof’s exterior appearance.

Get Expert Help with Your Historic Roof

Navigating historic district roofing requirements doesn’t have to be overwhelming. With the right guidance and a contractor who understands both preservation needs and modern roofing practices, you can maintain your home’s historic character while ensuring it remains well-protected.